Welcome to Toomey's Tavern
At Toomey's Tavern, a lively dive bar nestled along the water in Amityville, NY, the spirit of community thrives amidst a backdrop of great seafood and energizing live music. With a diverse menu featuring indulgent starters like homemade mozzarella sticks and crispy fish sandwiches, Toomey's caters to every palate, including vegetarian options. Guests can enjoy heated outdoor seating and the vibrant ambiance that's perfect for groups or a family outing. Whether you're there for the fantastic drinks or the friendly atmosphere, Toomey's Tavern is a destination where memorable dining experiences and unforgettable evenings come together.
Toomey's Tavern: Reviews & Ratings
Had lunch with friends very good service and food. will definately return very nice for a dive bar.
Awesome food, great ambiance and the drinks are on point! Staff was super friendly and overall great experience.
I had my son take us there for my Birthday.Had a lot of fun. We got there a little early but it started off well the water was right there they we're pulling in on boats and jet skis. The band started to play we ordered drinks and appetizers. The music was good the drinks were good the food was good. It was a great time and will definitely be back. The band that played was burn unit they were really good.!!!
My husband and I went to toomeys the past 2 fridays. It is so nice on the water and the bands are entertaining. Tonight we ordered 2 buckets of corona. On the menu, it lists buckets $25 for domestic & $30 for imported. On the bill it said 2 buckets= $70. I asked the waitress and she said it is $35 each when there is a band. If that is the case, they should have a different menu they hand out when they have a band or it should be noted that the price goes up. We didn't really need the 2nd bucket. I only had 1 beer from each and we actually had 1 we didn't even touch. I think it will be a while before I return bc being charged more than what is printed on the menu really left a bad taste in my mouth.
I came here last night for the first time! It's a cute dive bar on the water, and they play great music (mainly country). We didn't get any food here, but we grabbed a couple drinks and hung out for a bit. Vibes are awesome, and the people are all friendly. I'm glad I know about this spot now because I'll be coming here a lot during the summer.
Location
-
251 S Ketcham Ave Amityville, NY 11701 United States Hotline: (631) 264-0564
Introducing Toomey's Tavern:
Nestled at 251 S Ketcham Ave in Amityville, New York, Toomey's Tavern stands out as a vibrant dive bar that beckons seafood enthusiasts and casual diners alike. With its lively atmosphere, friendly service, and a menu that tantalizes the taste buds, it's clear why this local gem has become a favorite weekend haunt.
Atmosphere and Experience:
- Location: With its picturesque setting along the waterfront, Toomey's Tavern not only offers indoor seating but also extensive outdoor options, including heated and covered areas, making it a perfect spot for any season.
- Music and Ambiance: Known for its loud and spirited environment, Toomey's features live music on the weekends, enhancing the dining experience and making it a great place for dancing and socializing.
- Accessibility: The tavern is wheelchair accessible, ensuring that everyone can enjoy its offerings, while also being pet-friendly for those who wish to bring their dogs along for a meal.
- Family-Friendly: With many vegetarian options available and a casual atmosphere that caters to kids, it's a great choice for family outings.
Culinary Delights:
The menu at Toomey's Tavern features an array of delicious options that will leave you craving more:
- Appetizers: Start your journey with the Quesadilla, filled with your choice of chicken, steak, or shrimp, artfully complemented by melted Monterey Jack cheese and a drizzle of ranch. At just $12, it’s a delicious way to kick off your meal.
- Signature Dish: Try the Leo's Fish Sandwich, featuring beer-battered haddock served on a brioche roll with tartar sauce. Each bite bursts with flavor and is perfectly suited for a casual dining experience, also priced at $12.
- Sides and Desserts: Don't overlook the homemade potato chips or French fries, both available for just $4. For dessert, the Banana Cheese Cake Bites, lightly fried and drizzled in caramel and raspberry sauce, will leave you with a sweet finish to your meal.
Customer Testimonials:
Patrons have raved about their experiences at Toomey's Tavern. Paul N. noted the "very good service and food," expressing his eagerness to return. Carolyn T.'s birthday celebration was highlighted by lively music and delicious drinks, creating lasting memories.
While some guests shared mixed feelings regarding pricing during live performances, the overall ambiance and vibrancy of Toomey's Tavern clearly resonate with many. It's a place where fun and flavor align, inviting everyone to unwind and enjoy.
Whether you’re looking for a casual dinner, a bustling weekend night, or a spot to enjoy live music, Toomey's Tavern promises a memorable experience filled with great food, drinks, and a community spirit that keeps patrons coming back for more.
Connect: For reservations or inquiries, reach out at (631) 264-0564.
